Government ferry decision a case of political steering failure

The Government’s U-turn on purchasing new Interislander ferries is the predictable but costly outcome of flawed decision making.

The Mar­itime Union says the Government’s U‑turn on pur­chas­ing new Inter­is­lander fer­ries is the pre­dictable but cost­ly out­come of flawed deci­sion mak­ing.

The Gov­ern­ment has said it is now look­ing at build­ing new fer­ries again fol­low­ing the advice of the Min­is­te­r­i­al Advi­so­ry Group.

Mar­itime Union of New Zealand Nation­al Sec­re­tary Carl Find­lay says the ground­ing of the Aratere last week has now brought home the seri­ous­ness of the sit­u­a­tion of our inter-island fer­ries.

“The iRex project for new fer­ries and ter­mi­nals should have been recon­fig­ured rather than can­celled out­right.”??

He says the claimed sav­ings by the Gov­ern­ment do not stack up.  

“There needs to be an account­ing of costs incurred up to now, includ­ing any break fees, a far high­er price point for new builds ordered now, and a prob­a­ble five year wait for new ves­sels to come into ser­vice.”

Mr Find­lay says indus­try sources have sug­gest­ed that the all up cost of the new builds could be up to $1.2 bil­lion – more than dou­ble the $551 mil­lion cost of the ves­sels for the can­celled iRex project.

The cur­rent fer­ries will all be well over thir­ty years old by 2029. Main­te­nance costs have dou­bled on the age­ing fer­ries to an esti­mat­ed $65 mil­lion a year.

Mr Find­lay says it is unac­cept­able that crew and pas­sen­gers will be exposed to risk caused by fail­ure to invest in fer­ries and infra­struc­ture.

He expressed grave con­cern the pro­posed new fer­ries would not be rail capa­ble.

“This means dou­ble han­dling of con­tain­ers, adding sub­stan­tial costs for freight cus­tomers, delays and under­min­ing the sup­ply chain.”

Mr Find­lay says none of this takes into account that the Pic­ton and Welling­ton fer­ry ter­mi­nals both still require mod­ern­iza­tion.

The Mar­itime Union says new fer­ries have to be rail capa­ble and there needs to be a plan for ter­mi­nal upgrades in both Welling­ton and Pic­ton.

Share the Post:

Related Posts